Jasnik
1:42 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
I'd keep collins in as he is the in form player
|
whufcroe
1:17 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
"Stop this whole Bilic can do no wrong"
I've hardly said that
If someone is calling people idiots for picking Collins I see fuck all wrong with pointing out the manager is doing the same.
|
the exile
1:10 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
What Collins lacks in finesse he more than makes up for in strength, guts and determination. Even Alvin Martin at his best wasn't as dominant at the back as Collins has been in most of the games he has played this season. It's been great to watch.
|
i-Ron
1:08 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
No but you're suggesting he is to another poster purely because he fancies another player which is sad. It's like playground stuff. You calling my mum a slag? Kinda thing.
He played Nolan ahead of Lanzini once too. Stop this whole Bilic can do no wrong, and whatever he does I'm 100% behind, and belittling everyone for having an opinion that differs. You should be better than that!
|
WHUDeano
1:05 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Massive game tomorrow - win the next two and too 4 is in our hands.
|
solidbond
12:59 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Its out of ogbonna and Reid who partners Collins.
|
whufcroe
12:58 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
i-Ron 12:51 Sat Feb 6
I'm not calling Bilic an idiot for picking Collins am I?
Pretty simple stuff for me, who is in the best form?
As for the Southampton game, Bilic got it wrong for me in the first half and the team he put out played fucking shit. I guess he agreed as he made TWO changes at half time.
I may have gone a little OTT in the heat of the moment but you do love to bring stuff like this up for some reason. Sad really..........
|
i-Ron
12:51 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Ogbonna is a better player, Collins can be heroic though.
Also, if you're calling Bilic an idiot for picking him, don't forget he also tried to flog him last summer but Collins wanted to stay and fight for his place.
And let's not forget who was moaning that he looked clueless against Southampton at home at half time Croe!
|
AKA ERNIE
12:46 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Collins has been our best centre half this season by quite a long way
|
whufcroe
12:11 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Collins has been playing brilliantly which is why the manager has kept him in the side and that's the way it should be.
So is Bilic an idiot?
|
daveyg
12:09 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
I don't mind Collins,but I think both Ogbonna and Tomkins are better. Reid the best of them all.
He has the shirt because we haven't had a functioning right back and thus Tomkins has played there. Reid has been out injured so Ogbonna has played there instead.
I've just seen Collins make to many errors. That's my opinion and I reckon the vote on here is similar.
I will say he has been playing better under Bilic than Allardyce.
|
On The Ball
12:03 Sat Feb 6
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
I doubt anyone thinks that Collins is better than Ogbonna. I doubt Collins thinks he's better than Ogbonna! But that doesn't matter - it's who is playing best.
|
RH
11:49 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
You don't like Collins do you daveyg . The fact is he has the shirt and is playing well enough to keep it . Stop being a fool
|
whufcroe
11:47 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
daveyg 11:43 Fri Feb 5
So Bilic is a total fool?
Only on WHO
|
daveyg
11:43 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Those that think Collins is a better play than Ogbonna or Tomkins are total fools.
|
whufcroe
11:43 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
"I'd be interested to know how many of the games Valencia has played in that the team has failed to win."
Enner Valencia starts this season
Played 7 Won 4 Drawn 2 Lost 1
That's a 58% win ratio, 28% draw and 15% defeat
Diafra Sakho
Played 12 Won 6 Drawn 3 Lost 3
That's a 50% win ration 25% draw and 25% defeat
You're points not really stacking up Stubbo
Personally I really rate Sakho, think Carroll is an excellent player and was bang back in form and Enner is slowly finding his form now he's had his chance as a striker so we're pretty lucky if they can stay fit.
As I say, really can't seem to see why the negativity is there about Valencia but people seem to need scapegoats on here even when things are going so well.
|
Stubbo
11:42 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Knowing what we know of the next cup round, a question would be should we prioritise tomorrow or Tuesday. I'm assuming we'll go full strength tomorrow, but it's worth considering.
|
solidbond
11:38 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Ogbonna is not better than Collins .
|
Norflundon
11:27 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Not sure about that hinge has been excellent this season but I do think you should pick your best players and I think Reid and ogbonna are our best two
|
solidbond
11:25 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Those who think Collins shouldn't start are absolute fools.
|
chad sexington
11:21 Fri Feb 5
Re: Team V Southampton (Carroll back)
|
Start with Eminem.
|
| 
